The precautionary principle in practice is likely to be regarded as one of the foundation studies on the implementation of the precautionary principle. In 1997, the european commissions green paper on the general principles of eu food law mentions the precautionary principle as a fundamental principle of action in case of scientific uncertainty. In the last decade the precautionary principle has entered into the lexicon of modern environmentalism with remarkable speed and stealth. Precautionary principle states that when an activity causes some threat or harm to the public or the environment, general precautionary measures should be taken. The precautionary principle in eu law 24 introduction known. Peels book is one that i am sure will challenge and inform enormously scientists, academics and. Eu 2000 communication from the commission on the precautionary principle, com1, brussels.
The precautionary principle originated in german law as the vorsorgeprinzip which can. The current dialogue between the eu and the united states on the use and application of precaution is partly affected by confusion about the meaning of terms used in the debate. The precautionary principle pp has rapidly emerged as a staple of international environmental law and attempts have been made to extend it into. The application of the precautionary principle in practice. The precautionary principle is not defined in the treaties, which prescribes it only once to protect the environment article 1912, tfeu. This chapter begins by examining the development of the precautionary principle into a general principle of eu law.
When human activities may lead to morally unacceptable harm that is. The rationale is that modern technologies and human activities can inflict longterm, globalscale environmental damage and that conclusive scientific evidence of such damage may be available too late to avert it. The precautionary principle also is a cornerstone of european union eu environmental law and has been central in determining the eus position toward genetically modified organisms. The european union has continued to advance a precautionary approach through its new legislation. The classic definition of a precautionary approach comes from the 1992 rio declaration on. The precautionary principle in environmental science. The precautionary principle is not just an issue for the european union eu. Its desirable for the precautionary principle to be enshrined in uk law that carries over existing eu legislation referring to it or to be included in preambles to relevant legislation to ensure that decisions made under such legislation cannot be challenged in a uk court on the grounds that the hazard has not been. Humphries provides a valuable framework for understanding the concept, its legal and policy context and examines the extent to which the eu meets the legal and political challenges in balancing competing economic, environmental and social interests. In the realm of international environmental law the precautionary principle acquired intense and sustained attention, particularly since the principles inclusion in the rio declaration. Precautionary principle an overview sciencedirect topics.
Further detail is set out in european commission communication on the precautionary principle com 2000 1 2 february 2000. A key principle under eu law which provides a robust legal backstop against destruction of the environment the precautionary principle has been specifically ruled out of the bill as a means. The precautionary principle and international law, the. The precautionary principle as a device for greater environmental. What is the precautionary principle, and is it good or bad. The precautionary concept has become intrinsic to international environmental policy, especially with the adoption, in 1992, of the rio declaration at unced. Indicators that characterize the interpretation, and subsequent application of, the precautionary principle in practice in the eu. The precautionary principle in european community health. This is the legal status of the precautionary principle in the european union.
Trend of application of the precautionary principle weakstrong spectrum, based on. Precautionary principle glossary of summaries eurlex. The precautionary principle was introduced into food law by regulation ec 1782002 63 although it has been well established in other areas of law, notably environmental law, and is provided for in article 191 tfeu 64 ex article 174 of the ec treaty. The design and application of modern environmental law have been shaped by a set of principles and concepts outlined in publications such as our common future 1987, published by the world commission on environment and development, and the earth summits rio declaration 1992 the precautionary principle. This paper will argue that the precautionary principle applies at least to health protection as a core part of consumer protection and basically eu law is well equipped to deal with uncertainties. The eu has also advocated its extension to other areas, such as food and health issues. The precautionary principle precautionary principle. Product safety issuesby donna lambert, lovell white durrantrelated contentthe european commission has recently proposed a number of amendments to the general product safety directive 9259eec including a proposal that the precautionary principle should be taken into account when assessing the safety of a product. The precautionary principle european union regulations. The precautionary principle enables decisionmakers to adopt precautionary measures when scientific evidence about an environmental or human health hazard is uncertain and the stakes are high.
The precautionary principle in the european union the community has consistently endeavoured to achieve a high level of protection, among others in environment and human, animal or plant health. Under eu law, any risk management measures to be adopted while implementing the precautionary principle, have to be proportionate to ensure the. Precautionary principle law and legal definition uslegal. Though there is no shortage of books and articles on the legal status of the pp, legal scholarship is thin with regard to its relationship with climate change cc. Preventionprecaution trade v environment in eu law. Nanomaterials and the precautionary principle in the eu. Some say that the precautionary principle is impractical, since every implementation of a new technology carries some risk of negative consequence. The clash between international investment law and eu law i. The precautionary principle or precautionary approach is a strategy for approaching issues of potential harm when extensive scientific knowledge on the matter is lacking. The issue of when and how to use the precautionary principle, both within the european union and internationally, is giving rise to much debate, and. While the precautionary principle is found in some legal systems, such as germany, it is nonetheless relatively novel as a precept of administrative law. It has however become of increased importance in eu law.
An interesting question is, if the precautionary principle is accepted already as a general principle of international law in. Finally, the publication gives an overview of certain aspects of governance and the precautionary principle, namely risk governance, the sciencepolicy interface and the links between precaution and innovation. This brexit briefing provides an overview of the precautionary principle as it is currently interpreted and applied within the eu. In practice, in eu law, it has broader application and is also relevant to consumer policy and eu legislation. Precautionary principle too vague to be a viable policy. Author made an attempt to introduce the principle with relevant definitions. The precautionary principle in international environmental law. The precautionary principle is detailed in article 191 of the treaty on the functioning of the european union eu. The precautionary principle may only be invoked in the event of a potential risk and can never justify arbitrary decisions. When a scientific investigation proves that there is a possible risk in doing some activity, then this principle should be applied. He is currently writing a book on the eu internal market and the environment. In most cases, measures making it possible to achieve this high level of protection can be determined on a satisfactory scientific basis. The eus regulatory framework for chemicals regulation ec n 1907ec known as reach is based on the precautionary principle, as is its general regulation on food law regulation ec n 1782002.
The key element to the precautionary principle is the declaration adopted at the second international conference on the protection of the north sea in london in 1987. Case law of the cjeu on the precautionary principle. Precautionary principle wikimili, the best wikipedia reader. Risk bites dives into the precautionary principle, and provides an. The precautionary principle in uk environmental law and. Sep 15, 2019 precautionary principle calls for taking action against threatened harm to people and ecosystems even in the absence of full scientific certainty. The precautionary principle is a strategy to cope with possible risks where scientific understanding is yet incomplete, such as the risks of nano technology, genetically modified organisms and systemic insecticides. As one basic principle of international environmental law, the precautionary principle has been laid down or reflected in many multilateral environmental agreements.
The precautionary principle is designed to assist with decisionmaking under uncertainty and is a core principle of eu environmental law, enshrined in article 1912 of the treaty on the functioning of the eu. The eus regulatory framework for chemicals regulation ec n 1907ec known as reach is based on the precautionary principle, as is its general. Approaches from the nordic countries, eu and usa, earthscan, 2007. Abstractthe chapter aims to summarize the current knowledge and highlight further research directions on the role that the precautionary principle pp is likely to play in climate change. Also, it should not be forgotten the resolution on precautionary principle adopted by the european council of nice, which recommends member states to. Precautionary principle trade v environment in eu law.
It first emerged during the 1970s and has since been enshrined in a number of international treaties on the environment, in the treaty on the functioning of the european. Uk withdrawal bill rips the heart out of environmental. The precautionary principle or precautionary approach is a broad epistemological. Communication from the commission of 2 february 2000 on the precautionary principle com2000 1 final not published in the official journal. The application of the precautionary principle in practice by joakim. Ragnar lofstedt, 2014, the precautionary principle in the eu. The precautionary principle was introduced into food law by regulation ec 178200263 although it has. Jenneth parker 1998 shortly considers ethical assumptions of the precautionary principle in an introductory article. Plenty of people have an opinion on whether the precautionary principle is good or bad, but what exactly is it. Risk analysis and the precautionary principle as general principles of eu food law european institute for food law on. The precautionary principle, proposed as a new guideline in environmental decision making, has four central components. Susan carr 2002, for instance, has criticised the european unions negligence of the valuebased aspects of the principle. This chapter attempts to set the scene for this book on the rise of the precautionary principle in the environmental legislation of the nordic countries, chiefly by explaining the status of the principle in european community ec law and the manner in which it might influence further developments in those countries.
914 959 1492 665 1027 1276 510 331 577 1048 378 864 183 765 1538 1050 296 893 806 528 967 1424 1442 622 1050 832 153 942 1343 722 1304 1437 1195 191